Garretson wins the day to become mayor of Hillside in run-off election

HILLSIDE – Although Mayor Joe Menza was hoping to receive the support of voters in a run-off mayoral election yesterday against Councilwoman Angela Garretson, it failed to materialize. Garretson’s supporters converged on the polls, ushering her into the mayor’s seat by a margin of 380 votes.

The special election was held after the general election on Nov. 5 failed to give any candidate over 50 percent of the vote, which is required by Hillside’s form of government in order for a winner to be declared.

According to Union County Board of Elections Administrator Dennis Kobitz, Garretson ended up with 1,936 votes and Menza 1,556. These numbers did not include the 10 provisional, or paper ballots, which by law will be opened today.

In an interview with LocalSource, Garretson, admitted she was experiencing a wide range of emotions.

“This has been amazing journey and very humbling,” said the Democrat councilwoman who is wrapping up her first four-year term on the governing body.

The mayor elect said she felt very strongly that her campaign of focusing on bringing the community together and not being divisive helped voters decide she would be able to provide the leadership Hillside needs at this time.

“I think the residents of Hillside are tired of divisiveness and they want a mayor who can provide the leadership needed,” said Garretson, adding she ran for the mayor’s seat because she “had pride as a Hillside resident and I want our residents to feel that same pride in our town.”

Garretson said she plans to take her seat as mayor with a plan in hand and a transition team in place on Jan. 1 when she takes the oath of office.

“We need to go into town hall with a plan and a vision. I’m not going in blindly. I intend to give each employee and every resident the respect they deserve and provide transparency and accessibility,” she said, pointing out that she had strong feelings that people truly wanted change.

The mayor elect, though, is well aware she has her work cut out, but stressed that her mayoral style will be quite different from Menza’s.

“My leadership style is different than Joe’s, I plan to be receptive to what council’s vision is for Hillside and I will share my own vision with them,” Garretson said, adding that she intends to represent the people, not political interests.

Although Garretson did not have the support of Hillside’s Democrat Municipal Chairman Charlotte D’Filippo, those outside this camp, including Union County Democratic County Chairman Jerry Green, rolled out the red carpet when it came to support.

Garretson explained that thanks to Democrat leaders such as State Senator Ray Lesniak and Elizabeth Mayor Chris Bollwage, she was able to get her message to the community.

“I believe having the support of the unions and campaigning for more transparency really was effective,” she added.

Menza, on the other hand, was gracious about the loss, preferring to focus on what he achieved as mayor the last four years.

“I’m proud of what I’ve done. I think I was the right person at the right time for the job,” the mayor added.

“Look, I can be proud because when I became mayor four years ago I inherited a $3.6 million deficit and today we have no deficit, $800,000 in surplus, and two years running with a zero tax increase,” Menza explained, adding that Garretson has her work cut out.

“In Hillside you aren’t a ribbon cutting mayor, you are a working mayor and things get tough,” he said, mentioning that Garretson will face the same challenge he did – a council that controls the purse strings.

Would he do it all again if given the opportunity? Laughing heartily, Menza confesses that things were different four years ago.

“First of all I had a lot more hair and it wasn’t so gray,” he said, but there were moments that made it all worth it, such as in 2012 when he earned the title of Gateway Regional Chamber’s Mayor of the year.

“You have to love a moment like that because it speaks to who you are as a mayor of a community. Was it easy? No, it was a lot of work, but I’m proud to say I made changes that were needed and the taxpayers were the benefit of that,” Menza said.